In the Network: Media Co-opDominion   Locals: HalifaxMontrealTorontoVancouver

Support the Media Co-op
Donate today!

Useful Information

Sponsored Message:

Advertisement
Join the Media Co-op

My blog

Blog entries by Megan Kinch

posted by Megan Kinch
This photo of police running from protesters was widely shared on facebook.
This photo of protesters in the shape of a tree was also widely shared.

Two photos from two different Montreal protests from last weekend have gone viral on facebook. One, taken Friday April 20th at a militant demonstration of about 2000 students and activists against Plan Nord, was a photo of police running from protesters. The other was a photo of Sunday's huge Earth day protest in Montreal (April 22nd), where 200,000 – 300,000 people gathered. The mainstream media would like to contrast these demonstrations as opposed, one massive and peaceful, one small and militant.  Facebook, while allowing for a quick spread of photos, strips them of context in the way photos are being shared.  I was at both demonstrations and have been speaking to Montreal activists over the past week, and this is the story behind the photos.

I’ll start with the first picture, of cops running from protesters.  The police violence at the protest started when a demonstrator opened a door and was shot in the head point-blank with a tear gas canister.  This is when the protest became more militant.  Although there were one or two instances of police (including fully garbed riot police) running, these were the exception rather than the rule, and occured for very brief periods of time. Nonetheless, it might just mark a turning point in what many Quebecois are now calling ‘the Quebec spring.”

 I spoke to Claude, who was there as a protester when the cops turned and ran.

“Well I don’t know exactly what was the turning point, what made the police turn and run.  Actually, I was running from the policeman! And then I saw people all around me turn and start running the other way. So I turned as well, and started running after the policeman.  I don’t know. I cannot help you more than that...just that the energy was so strong from our side that we could beat the police. But it lasted like 30 seconds (laughter), and then tear gas came in and we ran from the police (more laughter)."

"Just to make a little context, I’m 41 years old" he continued.  "I’ve been in demonstrations  for almost 25 years now and I thought I had some experience with those kind of things. But I quickly understood that the kids there, they know everything, they know how to make a good demonstration, they know how to defend themselves, and I quickly realized that I had to listen to what they were saying and follow them. And that’s...

posted by Megan Kinch
Activists with a tar sands pipeline dragon during the environmental justice day of action at the G20 protests in 2010. (photo: Christian Peña)

 

The environmental justice movement has been distinguished by practicality as opposed to a particular ideological or tactical framework for action. This diversity was exemplified by Thursday’s panel- part of Latin American and Caribbean Solidarity Month, which featured a broad range of tactics from direct action, to community organizing to put political pressure on governments, to indigenous resistance, all together on one panel, bound by a common cause.

The environmental justice movement is reacting to changes in the global political context. Brent Patterson from council of Canadians talked about the need to fight the new UN ‘green economy” which he called the “financialization and commodification of nature and the privatization of public water’.  This kind of greenwashing of high finance indicates the limits of the traditional environmental movement, and the extent to which corporations and capitalism have adapted a ‘green’ rhetoric that does nothing to change the systemic exploitation of people and nature. Raul Burbano said: "Issues of environment, of water of austerity are all inter-related. The same issues we see here are the same as you see in the south and that is why solidarity is so important.”

Ben Powless, a Mohawk photojournalist speaking on behalf of the Indigenous Environmental Network, told the audience that “First nations are beginning to lead a lot of this resistance. We’re all on the front line in some way. Of course some communities are more directly affected, but we have to find our own front line and find a way to act from our own positions, from our own privileges”. Dave Vasey spoke about how living through Walkerton’s water crisis opened his eyes to the crisis of water contamination in indigenous communities and the systemic racism that makes Walkerton newsworthy but ignores even worse water problems on reserves. “Communities take action because the they have to.” he said. “And now we in Canada have to.”

The audience included many environmental justice activists, including Ron Plain from Aamjiwnaang First Nation near Sarnia, which has been described as the most polluted place in Ontario. It’s not often on the left that the question and answer period includes both people urging that struggles be channeled through the NDP, and Ron Plain talking about how when he was young he served a 6...

posted by Megan Kinch
Is the earthquake in Haiti a natural disaster of a human one? (photo courtesy of Roger Annis)

Sometimes you go to an event and are deeply moved by the testimony of one of the speakers. This happened to me yesterday at the event "Haiti: Solidarity and Social Justice".  Put on by the Worker's Assembly, the Latin American and Caribbean  Solidarity Network and the Haiti Action Committee, it featured excellent presentations by Roger Annis and Nicole Phillips on the current context in Haiti as it attempts to recover from the earthquake under the yoke of unaccountable NGOs and UN occupation, which I'll cover here on my TMC blog.  But first I'd like to post the entire transcript of a moving speech by Dr. Eric Pierre, the honorary consul for Haiti, on the deep historical context of the current Haitian crisis.

He addressed a crowd of about 60 people at Steelworkers hall:

"Usually the public attention in the so-called first world on the third world is limited to disasters and cases of corruption and coups and blood and cadavers on the sidewalks. Its like that primal taste for blood and anything that is terrible, that stinks. That’s what the public wants and that what they get. But you are here in the spirit of continued support to the Haitian people and I think this is very highly commendable and I certainty appreciate it a lot

Haitian history and the Haitian reality is complex…I cannot help saying that the earthquake is not a natural disaster. It is a human-made disasters and we have to remember that the holocaust we observed is due to the evil spirit of human begins, the ugly side of human nature. It is it is the end result, the combination the explosion of 500 years of treatment of human beings as lesser humans. And those efforts to deny people of their dignity, their rights to aspire to a certain participation in the fruits of their labour, those efforts were motivated by greed pursuit of profit as well as a mean spirited vendetta against the first African nation that defeated the colonial system. The first African nation to successfully say ‘no’- no to slavery, no to human rights abuses and the first African nation to force the world to listen.

Do not forget we are celebrating black history month. It’s a time for us to try to get that introspection to turn on ourselves and draw reasons to be proud and reason to continue fighting. Haiti pa...

posted by Megan Kinch
The author at Occupy Toronto.
Native participation in Saturday's march (photo: Mike Barber)
photo: Tristan Laing

When said we were heading to the 'occupy' protest, the cab driver turned off the meter. He told us he came here from Iran, that he had three degrees (two from Canada) and that he had to drive a cab every single day to make ends meet. “At least I don’t have a family to support” he said. “Isn’t that sad, that a man is happy he doesn’t have a family…I don’t want you thinking I’m a communist, because I’m not, but this system is not working.” We offered him money for the fare, and he absolutely refused, saying he could never take money from people like us, and that he wished he could be there. I had tears in my eyes as we left the cab and entered the park, which hummed with energy and activity.  An old man arrived to talk to the young people camping there: "There's revolution in the air" he told us. I have a book on my shelf with that title, but I never thought I’d hear that phrase told to me in person. Revolution- it’s suddenly outside of old books, branch meetings, anarchist bookfairs and freeschool discussion groups to become a word that people on the street are actually using. 

I can hardly believe that it hasn't been two weeks yet since Occupy Toronto started. A mini-village has emerged in St. James Park, functional despite growing pains in setting up governance from scratch in a charged environment. It's been a rapid learning curve for everyone- for new people who've thrown themselves into political activity, for experienced activists trying to figure out what is going on. I think about other political actions I've been involved in (like the three-month teaching assistant strike, anti mining campaigns, and the G20 protests), but never have I been part of something that's been a game changer on the political scene, not just in Toronto but across North America, even becoming part of ongoing political uprising in Europe. (Although we certainly had our delusions about the CUPE 3903 strike while it was on. I'm quite aware that being involved in an action creates a kind myopia that makes it impossible to judge its actual importance.)

 Most of the time, politics are slow.  Door-knocking, tabling, innumerable lectures, meetings, meeting, meetings. And then sometimes it happens fast. What are the demands?' people keep asking.  I really don't know how it could be clearer. People...

posted by Megan Kinch

(this is an opinion piece originally posted on my blog)

I've been really excited about the 'occupy' movement and have been watching it develop. Like many others on the 'existing left', I was one of those who argued to give it space, let it grow.  And I went to the meeting on Friday to see how I can help and how the organization I'm with can maybe contribute to this process. I left the meeting with very grave concerns about democracy and the development of a culture of coercive agreement in the name of consensus.  

The meeting started off on a bad foot as about 250 people gathered in a park at Front and Church.  Thomas Zaugg, who seemed to be some kind of coordinator despite not owning his leadership, made the announcement that we weren't going to be discussing politics, and also that he'd spoken to 52 division the day before.  The meeting erupted in consternation- if there is one thing the assembled crowd did not have an agreement on it was the cops, the black bloc, violence etc. Many people questioned what gave him the authority to speak with cops on the behalf of the group.  He did eventually apologize for acting on behalf of the group without its permission.

However, I've recently heard that not only did he speak to police but also to CSIS, and that he knew there was a CSIS officer present at the meeting. He did not inform the meeting of this fact. I find this very disturbing. While its good activist practice to assume that there are police at any open event (or non-open even for that matter), many people at the meeting are new and won't make that assumption, so it needs to be announced, especially if there is positive information that there is CSIS at the meeting. This is not keeping in mind the safety of those assembled and people's rights to make their own decision about the level of risk they want to be exposed to.

There were clear leaders who had been organizing with the ‘occupy ‘ on the internet, but some of them didn’t announce themselves and seemed to think we would already know who they were 'from the internet'.  The woman who ended up doing most of the facilitating was from the Peoples Assembly, a group I really respect and have worked with before, and...

posted by Megan Kinch

 

This morning my boyfriend and I went to vote at the poll in Toronto.  We actually had voting cards and were on the registration list, a rarity for most people our age, but because the last election was so recent we were on the list for once. Now, according to Elections Ontario, a voting card is proof of residence. However, his driver’s license claimed that he lives with his parents in North York. Like many young people who move a lot, he uses his parents address for mailing and the like as its not worth it to update his address every year or so. The people at the driver’s license office were fine with this when he asked. But not the voting people. No, they didn't like this discrepancy and said he needed to return with a bill from Bell or some kind of mail.  He got the mail and managed to vote, but the man at the desk told him that cops might get him in trouble if they caught him having a different address on his license (even if its his parents). Great, lets threaten people with the police when they go to vote. The other thing that is messed up is that they never checked my ID, and my driver's license says I live in Oshawa and I voted with no problems.  I can't help but attribute this to the fact that I am unambiguously white where he looks Mediterranean or Middle Eastern.  

Elections Canada is pretty clear that your voting card is proof of residence and the driver's license is proof of ID, but the supervisor I talked to still insisted that he get a phone bill or something.  How does this make sense? Why is a bill from a private company more valid that mail from the government?  I'm offended by their "We make voting easy" campaign. Its easy for some people, maybe. I'm growing more and more concerned about the slow erosion of even the limited 'democratic rights' that that we have.

Of course, landed immigrants can't vote at all, nor can residents without status, people without secure housing or people without ID. But even given those very clear discriminations, the way that voting is administered discriminates against renters and people who move a lot-  basically poor people.   I don...

posted by Megan Kinch

Note: the spelling and editing of this blog post is totally not up to my usual standards. I wrote it in a huge hurry before the jail solidarity rally on Monday, fully expected to be arrested and thrown in the detention centre i describe here. Please forgive me...

After leading some chants at jail solidarity yesterday and escaping down a back alley, i was feeling very conspicious walking down the street, as police were stopping people for no reason and sometimes arresting them. I ended up going to a friends house near the temporary facility at Eastern and Pape. My friend had been having a barbeque from "Fightback" ("the marxist voice of labour and youth"), but not many members had shown up (please note: I am not a member of fightback).  It turned out that large numbers of them, including my roomate, had been arrested the night before at the Novotel, when peacefull protesters were penned in with nowhere to go and arrested en mass. Most of the crew from Fightback were from the local Esplenade area. The only way we knew our roomate had been arrested was because he stopped answering his cell phone.

The party quickly turned into a debrief centre for the political prisoners as they began to be released one by one.  The first one released, Allan, was released into the pouring rain without his shoes. People doing solidarity outside started canting "Where's his shoes! Where's his shoes!". Many of the released were incredibly disoriented, without money, some of thier belongings stolen, having no idea where they were. People who weren't part of an organized group, like the comrades I was with, were in serious trouble as there was no support whatsoever, and the volunteers outside who were helping people were periodically attaced by riot police.

The second person released, my roomate, was soaking wet and had been in the freezing detention centre with only a light cotton t-shirt. They had been given nothing to eat except a few cheese sandwhices that were consited of a hamburger bun with one slice of proccessed cheese.  They had not been able to phone a lawyer, and had had their own cell phones confiscated.

One member of Fightback, who had a car, picked up the disoriented and soaked detainees from the release point at the gate of the Eastern ave. facility as night began to fall.  As more people started coming in, we put them in showers and started cooking food and hot tea for them. They...

User login

Advertisement