I wrote some of this originally in response to yet another "debate" about "violence" by "anarchists" in the G20 demonstrations. None of these thoughts are original; they are parsed together from the mingling of my own experiences with the myriad conversations I've had or read in response to the public outcry about burning cruisers and smashed windows on Saturday. In particular, I am adding my voice to those who have already expressed frustration with those individuals and institutions on the Left who have felt it necessary to use the limited airtime they have on joining the chorus of condemnation of window-smashing. The line we now hear, from Mayor David Miller, from police chief Bill Blair, from OFL President Sid Ryan, is that "a few violent idiots ruined an otherwise peaceful protest on Saturday." This, we are told, is the reason that police had to crackdown on protestors, even the peaceful ones.
It shocks me to think that institutions of the Left - long the victims of police intimidation and violence - would so quickly and happily take up the very rhetoric of the police themselves. It is as if time stopped in the middle of the afternoon on Saturday; all that was past was forgotten, the story begins now. Protestors are breaking windows. This is where the rest of the narrative starts.
But there was police violence long before any windows were smashed. About two months ago, 18-year old Junior Alexander Manon was murdered by police on the York University campus. He was not charged with any crime - he was in a car that was stopped by police and, like so many youths in the Jane-Finch community, his first instinct in a community terrorized by police was to run. Eyewitnesses described his being chased down by the uniformed officers and beaten to his death; first emergency response teams described finding him in a pool of his own blood. They were quickly told to shut up and the police claimed Manon had died of cardiac arrest. Despite the family's insistence that his case be publicly investigated, police have refused to allow the public to see the autopsy report, which would have so easily cleared everything up is he had, indeed, simply died of a heart attack.
Why has there has not been any discussion or outcry - complete with dramatic full colour photos - about violence by police in the past two months, coming out of the killing of Manon? Police...
Comments posted by Tyler Shipley