Toronto Media Co-op

Local Independent News

More independent news:
Do you want free independent news delivered weekly? sign up now
Can you support independent journalists with $5? donate today!

Safety and Rights of Journalists in Canada

by Kate Raynes-Goldie From Flickr, with creative commons liscense
by Kate Raynes-Goldie From Flickr, with creative commons liscense

Following the Toronto G20 protests last June, four journalists filed complaints with the Office of Independent Police Review Director, Ontario’s police watchdog. The complaints by Amy Miller, Daniel McIsaac, Jesse Rosenfeld and Lisa Walter include allegations of physical assaults, verbal abuse, gender discrimination and threats of sexual violence by Toronto police. All four journalists, now known as the ‘Free Press 4’ group, claim that they did not break any laws and that police knew that they were journalists.

Miller was threatened with gang rape and police allegedly told her that she would never want to “act” as a journalist again after they were done with her. Rosenfeld was physically beaten several times when police mistook him for someone else and kept punching him even though he was not resisting arrest. Walter was thrown to the ground and arrested, called a “f-ing dyke” and a “douche bag”, handcuffed with plastic ties for 13 hours, denied her medication for nine and segregated in the G20’s makeshift prison for possibly being a queer. As well, her video camera’s hard drive had been erased and the memory card had been confiscated. McIsaac was also assaulted and arrested.

The scale of physical violence and intimidation against these reporters appears to be unprecedented in Canadian history. The Committee to Protect Journalists, which keeps a record of violations against journalists and suppression of the freedom of the press, does not have any incidents in its files that resemble what took place at the G20. The lawyers representing the Free Press 4 are not aware of such extreme policing actions in Canada’s history either.

Certainly, journalists in Canada have been barred, inconvenienced and threatened with danger from doing their job in the past. However, it is unheard of for police to intimidate, harass, arrest and abuse without any warning and at the drop of a hat.

The incident that comes closest to this is the Oka Crisis of 1990, a land dispute between the Mohawks and the town of Oka, Quebec. In addition to seizing footage of a confrontation between the Mohawks and police, the Canadian Armed Forces erected a razor wire perimeter which journalists were prevented from crossing. The perimeter was intended to isolate the Mohawks. However, journalists were trapped inside the perimeter as well and the police barred the supply of notebooks, tapes and batteries into the perimeter. The flow of food and other essential supplies was also limited thereby endangering the journalists’ health. The Canadian Association of Journalists described the censorship as “one of the worst attacks ever on the Canadian public’s right to know.

While the police tried to manipulate what the journalists could report and how well they could report, intimidations were never as overt as seen during the G20 summit, nor was there any physical violence, verbal abuse or discrimination.

Jackie Esmonde, one of the lawyers advocating for the Free Press 4, highlights the fact that all the members of the Free Press 4 are reporters for alternative media. When police saw their alternative media accreditation, they essentially told them that they did not consider them to be real journalists, that their accreditation was “garbage” or “fake” and that they should get “real” jobs. “These are new forms of media. It’s of concern that they are not seen as legitimate especially since media and ways of reporting are changing. These new frontiers serve a very important function and there has to be protection for that,” says Esmonde.

There are reports of several other journalists, many of whom work for alternative media, who faced the same fate as the Free Press 4. The experience of CTV field producer Farzad Fatholahzadeh, also arrested during the summit, is slightly different. Once police realized who they had arrested, they fast-tracked his release and dropped the charges.

So, what does all this mean for Canadian society as a democracy?

“It’s fundamental to democracy that the public has information about the state. Journalists and media are essential to that,” says Esmonde. On the other hand, Neil Thomlinson, an associate professor in the Department of Politics and Public Administration at Ryerson University, offers a different perspective.

“Freedom of the press is important so that journalists are able to do their job. However, I don’t think anybody should have the responsibility to ensure that journalists are able to do their job,” says Thomlinson who feels very strongly that journalists do not have a higher calling. “What happened is that they got treated the same as everybody else. The point is nobody should be treated that way.”

Thomlinson says that Canadians have a dangerously complacent attitude in believing that such victimization by the police is always somebody else’s problem until they themselves get arrested.

“It is this attitude that elects a government that can trample over citizen’s rights that are already included in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The current federal government does not respect these rights. We need to change this attitude. ”

In the meantime, Ontario’s police watchdog is conducting a systemic review of policing during the G20 summit. The Office of Independent Review Director was created in October 2009 as an arms-length agency reporting to the Attorney-General. The review is significant because a systemic review of policing has never been done before. Typically, when the Director’s Office receives a complaint against Toronto police, they forward the complaint to Toronto Police Services who deal with the complaints on an individual basis and then report their results to the Director’s Office.

It is not known how long it will take the Office to review the complaints. Esmonde says they appear to be moving as fast as they can. She says,

“Our hope is that there will be recommendations not only addressing the policing at G20, but there needs to be acknowledgement of alternate media.”

Want more grassroots coverage?
Join the Media Co-op today.

Creative Commons license icon Creative Commons license icon

About the poster

Trusted by 1 other users.
Has posted 1 times.
View Vidya Kauri's profile »

Recent Posts:

Vidya Kauri (Vidya Kauri)
Member since October 2010


957 words


Thanks for writing this

Thanks for writing about this important issue and keeping it before the public eye. Good analysis of the significance of the problem.

Thank you for reminding us

Now that the mainstream media has moved on, I am thankful that alternative journalists are still doing their jobs and following up on stories. Without media coverage, I wonder if our civil liberties would be taken away from us entirely behind our backs.

How can I get accreditation

How can I get accreditation as a journalist?  How qualifies and who doesnt?  It all depends on the size of their employer. 

Maybe what we need is an Ontario College of Journalists that can accredit the profession.  Similar to the accredation that teachers, dentists, physiotherapists go through.  This make journalists status independent of their employment status

Nothing here about the Black

Nothing here about the Black Bloc specifically targeting journalists with violence and intimidation? This argument cuts both ways.

1. I suspect that the Black

1. I suspect that the Black Bloc has actually been infiltrated by the police and other government agents, and that they might be composed of agent provocateurs. I would love for someone to prove me wrong.

2. Unlike the police, the Black Bloc is not a government organization that our taxes support and that is expected to keep its citizens safe from harm and violence. Journalists could be attacked by anybody for being in the profession that they are in. It becomes a huge problem for democracy when those attacks come from our elected government.


We've already been over this. They weren't. 

The kid that tried to grab my camera, and when that failed threw a chunk of concrete at my head, defiantly wasn't... 

Hey Mike, I never said that

Hey Mike,

I never said that the Black Bloc was entirely composed of agents provocateurs. I am sure that there are many who are part of the organization with their own agenda. However, I wouldn't be surprised at all if the police (and maybe even CSIS) have infiltrated their ranks, or possibly even paying some of the members to cause destruction. (For the record, I am not a Black Bloc sympathizer.) Again, the Black Bloc do not have a special mandate to protect citizens from harm, least of all journalists, unlike the police who benefit from our taxes.

p.s: I'm sorry that somebody

p.s: I'm sorry that somebody threw concrete at your head and I hope your injury was not too bad. Completely unacceptable.

no worries, they're aim was a

no worries, his aim was a little off.

Important story.  The lack of

Important story.  The lack of police accountability is blatant in these cases. 

The site for the Toronto local of The Media Co-op has been archived and will no longer be updated. Please visit the main Media Co-op website to learn more about the organization.